Summary: Which backup Software to use?

From: Andrew Watkins (andrew@dcs.bbk.ac.uk)
Date: Mon Feb 28 2000 - 10:32:25 CST


Hi,

As someone said I opened a can of worms here! But here are the stats first:

Solstice Backup 5 (Legato Re-badged)
Legato NetWorker 7
Veritas Netbackup 7
Segate Backup Exec 1
Arkeia 2
Alexandria 1
Amanda 1

Total 24 replies

Comments I had were:

1) Backup modules are used, but due to the cost they are kept down to the min.
        - Oracle hardly used, can get by with out it
        - MS SQL and MS Exchange used.
        
2) Client pre- and post scripts are used to start/stop databases.

3) Performance problems with NT server!

4) Installing and setup seem to cause most problems.

5) O'Reilly again are here! http://www.sysadminmag.com/current/books.shtml

It looks like the fight is between Legato and Veritas, but if you include
Solstice into the figures then Legato is a winner, but I wonder is that more to
do with this list (Sun-Managers). It may come down to hardware support, since
we are going for a Mammoth-2 (60-150Gbytes on one tape), which has just been
launched!!

Thanks for all the e-mail

"Marco Breedeveld" <marco.breedeveld@capgemini.nl>
"Rodney Wines" <Rodney.Wines@ahqps.alcatel.fr>
Rick Brashear <rickb@colltech.com>
Paul Pescitelli <pbp@mindspring.com>
Matt Reynolds <Matt.Reynolds@aztek-eng.com>
<dharringt@deq.state.va.us> (David B. Harrington)
chuck.h.dugan@sb.com
"Day, David" <dday@sous.com>
rye@jwfc.jfcom.mil
John Bonura <johnb@univ-wea.com>
"Dom Hayes" <ITNDH@mailer.rgu.ac.uk>
"Don Krause" <dkrause@proton.llumc.edu>
"Rasana Atreya" <rasana_atreya@hotmail.com>
"Joel Lee" <Joel.Lee@avnet.com>
foster@dim.ucsd.edu
Rich Kulawiec <rsk@gsp.org>
Doug Harmon <dharmon@justice.loyola.edu>
Rahul Parasnis <rahul.parasnis@creditlyonnais.fr>
"Karsten Koepp" <koepp@lausitz.net>

Cheers

Andrew Watkins

Question:

> I have been looking at the archives and have not been able to find much about
> the above. There has been a lot of talk about backup devices, but not
> much about the software to go with it.
>
> I have been using amanda software, but I would like to find out what people
> are using, since we are about to get a bigger tape autoloader and wonder
> is it tike to switch software.
>
> Thinks which I would like to fine out.
> - Which software do you use to backup your system.
> - Do you have a mixed environment (UNIX/NT)
> - Do you use the extra Database backup modules (Oracle,SQL,etc) or do
> you get by with out them, since the cost of them is to high.
>
> I will summaries, since I believe this could be interesting to most of us.



This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.2 : Fri Sep 28 2001 - 23:14:03 CDT